The celebration of romance, inspired by a Christian saint, is unwelcome where it’s seen as foreign and immoral.
ByErin Blakemore
Published February 11, 2022
• 6 min read
Hearts, flowers, and kisses are part and parcel of Valentine’s Day, which has been celebrated with displays of romance and affection for centuries in some Western nations. In an Ipsos survey of people in 28 countries around the world, a whopping 55 percent of respondents said they planned to mark the occasion with their partner. But for people in some parts of the globe, celebrating the holiday—which marks the feast day of St. Valentine, a Christian martyr—is taboo or even illegal: Religious edicts and concerns about the spread of Western commercial culture have quashed the annual February 14 festival of lovers.
From bans to mass arrests and even threats of forced marriage, here’s where it’s been discouraged, or downright dangerous, to embrace the day.
Saudi Arabia
For decades, February 14 was just another day in Saudi Arabia, which banned Valentine’s Day as antithetical to Islamic notions of propriety. Though some people cautiously exchanged gifts and flowers in February, they ran the risk of a run-in with the nation’s religious police until about five years ago.
The change came after Saudi Arabia’s crown prince Mohammad bin Salman stripped the nation’s Committee for the Promotion of Virtue and Prevention of Vice, a department once charged with enforcing strict religious norms, of many of its powers in 2016. Before that, people who dared to celebrate the holiday were often arrested, and shop owners were prevented from selling Valentine’s Day goods.
Since then, reports Al Arabiya English, Saudis have openly embraced the holiday and the prices of flowers and heart-studded gifts—long inflated because of the secrecy surrounding the holiday—have fallen.
Pakistan
The holiday is a bone of contention in Pakistan. In 2016, the nation’s then president Mamnoon Hussain urged Pakistanis to avoid Valentine’s Day, telling a gathering of mostly female students that the holiday “has no connection with our culture.” The remarks, which were widely construed as a sign of support by the nation’s Islamic hardliners, spurred a 2017 ban by the nation’s high court and an edict to remove all traces of Valentine’s Day from public spaces and to ban merchandise, advertising, or promotion of the holiday in the media.
That hasn’t dampened enthusiasm for some Pakistanis. Despite police interference and surveillance, romantic rebels find ways to acquire flowers and give their lovers sentimental gifts for the holiday, though most do so under wraps.
“People are still going to go out and do their thing and have fun — maybe just in different ways,” one scofflaw who planned to make his wife a romantic breakfast on February 14 told the New York Times in 2018. “You can’t ban love.”
Malaysia
Malaysian authorities have also done their best to do away with the holiday. In 2005, the nation’s Fatwa Council, which interprets Islamic law and makes decrees, declared Valentine’s Day antithetical to Islam because it had “elements of Christianity.” Though Christian groups urged the council to reconsider, claiming there is little connection between the modern Valentine’s Day and Christianity, the ban persisted.
Religious authorities upped the ante after that, when they began mass arrests of couples suspected of celebrating the holiday. In one incident in 2011, authorities in Selangor and Kuala Lumpur targeted couples in budget hotels and public parks, the BBC reported, calling the holiday synonymous “with vice activities.”
Iran
Religious authorities in Iran have turned to the public for help prosecuting those who celebrate the holiday in defiance of strict religious laws. The government has long banned symbols of the day, warning that they are “anti-cultural,” and condemned Valentine’s Day as a sign of immorality and Western decadence.
But Valentine’s Day has grown so popular that some Islamic hardliners now encourage observing an ancient Iranian holiday, Sepandārmazgān, instead. The holiday, which falls on February 23, is known as a Persian day of love honoring Spandarmad, a Zoroastrian deity who represented a loving wife.
That hasn’t kept many Iranians from celebrating the Western holiday in secret too, despite a ban on the production and sale of Valentine’s cards and other trinkets.
India
In India, extreme Hindu nationalists have protested the holiday and threatened those who celebrate, even attacking young couples and cutting their hair or blackening their faces.
A notable anti-Valentine campaign focused on social media platforms, where 518 million Indians were estimated to be active as of 2020. In 2015, a fringe far-right Hindu political party threatened to force people who made public displays of love on social media for Valentine’s Day to marry, and threatened to force anyone it found celebrating the holiday in public into impromptu nuptials, too.
Insights, advice, suggestions, feedback and comments from experts
I am an expert and enthusiast assistant. I have access to a wide range of information and can provide insights on various topics. I can help answer questions, engage in discussions, and provide information based on search results and my knowledge base.
Now, let's discuss the concepts mentioned in this article.
Valentine's Day:
Valentine's Day is a holiday celebrated on February 14th in many Western countries. It is associated with romantic love and is often marked by the exchange of gifts, such as flowers, chocolates, and cards, between loved ones. The holiday has its roots in the feast day of St. Valentine, a Christian martyr. Over the centuries, Valentine's Day has become a popular celebration of love and affection.
Bans and Discouragement:
In some parts of the world, celebrating Valentine's Day is discouraged or even banned due to various reasons, including religious and cultural concerns. Here are a few examples mentioned in the article:
-
Saudi Arabia: For many years, Valentine's Day was banned in Saudi Arabia due to its perceived conflict with Islamic notions of propriety. Celebrating the holiday could lead to arrests and restrictions on selling Valentine's Day goods. However, in recent years, the ban has been lifted, and Saudis have openly embraced the holiday.
-
Pakistan: Valentine's Day has been a bone of contention in Pakistan. In 2017, the nation's high court banned the celebration of Valentine's Day in public spaces and prohibited the promotion of the holiday in the media. Despite the ban, some Pakistanis continue to celebrate the holiday in secret.
-
Malaysia: In Malaysia, the Fatwa Council declared Valentine's Day antithetical to Islam in 2005, citing its perceived Christian elements. Subsequently, there were mass arrests of couples suspected of celebrating the holiday. The ban on Valentine's Day merchandise and celebrations has persisted.
-
Iran: In Iran, religious authorities have banned symbols of Valentine's Day, considering them "anti-cultural." Celebrating the holiday is seen as a sign of immorality and Western decadence. However, the popularity of Valentine's Day has led some Islamic hardliners to encourage observing an ancient Iranian holiday called Sepandārmazgān, which falls on February 23rd.
-
India: In India, extreme Hindu nationalists have protested Valentine's Day and threatened those who celebrate it. There have been instances of attacks on young couples and attempts to force them into impromptu marriages. Anti-Valentine campaigns have also been conducted on social media platforms.
These examples highlight the varying attitudes and restrictions surrounding the celebration of Valentine's Day in different parts of the world.
Please note that the information provided is based on the search results and may not reflect the current situation in these countries.
